This week, the NSW Government pressed pause on its long-awaited underquoting reforms, just hours before they were due to take effect.
Premier Chris Minns announced the decision on 16 November, following concerns that some of the proposed changes could create unintended consequences in a weakening property market.
The new commencement date is now 1 December 2027.
There is a legitimate argument that parts of the legislation needed further consideration. Property prices do not always rise, vendors can change their expectations, and agents need to be able to respond to changing market conditions.
But the decision raises a much bigger question: If the proposed legislation was not fit for purpose, what is the Government going to do about the problem it was designed to address?
Delaying the reforms does not make underquoting disappear.
1. A last-minute change that raises more questions than it answers
The reforms were intended to improve transparency and accountability in residential property advertising.
Among other things, they would have required agents to display a selling price or price range in advertisements, rather than relying on expressions such as ‘Price on Application’. They also intended to introduce more prescriptive requirements around comparable sales, documenting price estimates and updating advertising when estimates changed.
A further stage was to introduce a mandatory Statement of Information, giving prospective buyers access to the evidence supporting an agent’s price estimate.
Importantly, existing underquoting laws remain in force. Agents must still ensure their estimated selling price is reasonable, revise it when it is no longer reasonable, and must not advertise or quote below the estimated selling price recorded in the agency agreement.
Therefore, this is not a suspension of underquoting laws. It is a postponement of additional transparency and compliance measures.
2. The problem buyers have been complaining about for years
Anyone who has spent time seriously searching for property in Sydney will understand the frustration.
A property is advertised at $1.5 million. A buyer considers it affordable, arranges an inspection, researches comparable sales, perhaps obtains a building report and spends time considering an offer.
Then the agent indicates that the vendor is expecting something closer to $1.7 million or $1.8 million.
Sometimes the guide moves upwards during the campaign. Sometimes the advertised range appears to have little relationship to the eventual selling price. And sometimes buyers discover that the property was never realistically within their budget.
This is more than an inconvenience. Buyers have limited time, particularly those balancing demanding jobs and family commitments. They may spend weekends inspecting unsuitable properties, incur due diligence costs and make financial decisions based on price information that does not accurately reflect the market.
There is also a broader consequence. When buyers repeatedly encounter unrealistic price guides, confidence in the entire sales process deteriorates.
They become more sceptical of advertised prices, less willing to engage with agents and more likely to assume that every property will sell well above its guide.
That is not a healthy market for buyers, sellers or the industry.
3. A price guide is not a promise
It is important to distinguish between underquoting and an agent getting the price wrong.
A price guide is an estimate, not a guaranteed selling price. The eventual result can be influenced by competition, buyer demand, the property’s presentation, market conditions and the individual circumstances of the vendor.
A property advertised at $1.5 million may ultimately sell for $1.8 million without necessarily having been underquoted.
The relevant question is whether the original estimate was reasonable when it was made and whether it remained reasonable as the campaign progressed.
This is where the distinction becomes important. An agent should not be penalised simply because a property sells above expectations. But nor should an agent be able to rely on an unrealistically low estimate to attract a larger pool of prospective buyers.
The industry needs to be able to distinguish between genuine market movement and deliberately misleading price guidance.
4. Why the proposed rules ran into trouble
The Government’s decision was prompted by a legitimate concern about how the legislation would operate in a falling market.
Consider a vendor who receives a written offer of $1.5 million and rejects it because they believe their property is worth $1.6 million.
Several weeks later, market conditions deteriorate. Buyer interest weakens, comparable sales soften and the vendor decides they would now accept $1.4 million.
Under the proposed restrictions, agents could have been prevented from advertising below a previously rejected written offer or the highest unsuccessful auction bid. In this scenario, they would be prevented from advertising a guide of $1.4m even though the vendor’s expectations had changed and the market no longer supported the original price.
The intention was understandable: Stop agents advertising properties at prices that vendors had already demonstrated they would not accept. But the practical consequences could have been problematic.
A vendor’s expectations can change. Their financial circumstances can change. And, particularly in a declining market, the value of their property can change.
A regulation designed to prevent misleading price guides should not inadvertently prevent an agent from communicating a genuine reduction in the price a vendor is prepared to accept.
The Government was therefore right to recognise that the legislation needed to work in both directions.
However, this also raises an uncomfortable question. Property markets move in cycles. Why was this possibility not adequately addressed before the reforms were finalised and agencies had begun preparing for their introduction?
5. Who is accountable?
There is responsibility on both sides of this debate.
The Government must accept that legislation needs to be properly considered, tested and developed in consultation with the people who will be required to comply with it.
A last-minute postponement, after the industry had spent considerable time and money preparing for the changes, is hardly a model of effective regulation.
But the real estate industry should not use the Government’s decision as an opportunity to dismiss the underlying problem.
Underquoting has been a persistent source of frustration for buyers. It damages confidence and undermines the credibility of professional agents who provide accurate and honest advice.
The fact that some proposed regulations may have been impractical does not mean that the existing arrangements are satisfactory.
Good agents should welcome greater transparency. It provides an opportunity to distinguish professional conduct from practices that give the industry a poor reputation.
Ultimately, buyers should not have to rely on an agent’s verbal assurance that a property is within their budget. They should have access to meaningful information that allows them to make their own assessment.
6. What sensible reform should look like
The answer is not necessarily more regulation for its own sake. It is better regulation.
Any revised framework should be built around several straightforward principles.
First, price estimates should be evidence-based. Agents should be able to demonstrate how they arrived at their estimates, using genuinely comparable recent sales rather than selectively chosen examples that support an artificially low figure.
Second, there should be clear documentation. An agent’s estimate should be recorded, supported by evidence and capable of being independently scrutinised if challenged.
Third, price guides should be reviewed throughout a campaign. If new comparable sales, buyer feedback or changing market conditions mean the original estimate is no longer reasonable, it should be revised promptly.
Fourth, buyers should have access to useful information. A properly prepared Statement of Information would be a positive development, provided it contains meaningful comparable sales rather than simply satisfying a compliance requirement.
Finally, enforcement needs to be meaningful. Existing laws are of limited value if buyers have little confidence that misleading conduct will be identified and penalised.
None of these principles should prevent an agent from adjusting a price guide downwards when market conditions genuinely warrant it.
The objective should be accountability, not inflexibility.
7. Where does this leave buyers?
For now, buyers in NSW need to continue approaching advertised prices with a degree of caution.
The existing laws still prohibit underquoting, but the additional transparency measures have been delayed. That means buyers should not assume that every advertised price represents a reliable indication of what a vendor is prepared to accept.
Look beyond the guide. Research recent comparable sales, understand the differences between properties and, where possible, establish an independent view of value before becoming emotionally or financially committed.
Most importantly, do not confuse an advertised price with a realistic purchasing opportunity.
Ultimately, underquoting is about trust. Buyers should be able to take a price guide seriously, understand the evidence behind it and have confidence that it represents a genuine assessment of market value, rather than simply a figure designed to generate enquiry.
A property market cannot function properly when buyers don’t trust the prices they see advertised.
Until the Government gets these reforms right, buyers need to be better informed, more sceptical of advertised price guides and prepared to do their own research.
This is one of the issues I regularly explore inside the Sydney Buyers’ Domain on Skool, where I share practical buying advice, market analysis and resources to help buyers make better-informed property decisions.
If you’re looking to buy in Sydney, or simply want to become a more informed buyer, I’d encourage you to join the community.


